Designer cakes & desserts, baked to order in Ohio.
Every cake is thoughtfully designed, carefully baked from scratch, and finished with meticulous attention to detail — transforming everyday treats into edible works of art. From vintage buttercream cakes to indulgent Basque cheesecakes, we bake for life's sweetest moments.
Customer Favorites
View full menu →Raspberry Vintage Cake
Fresh raspberries & baby's breath
English Bloom Cake
Dried baby's breath & pink rosettes
Gender Reveal Cake
Pink or blue surprise inside
Signature Basque Cheesecake
Caramelized top, creamy center
Cheesecake Cupcakes
Our Signature Biscoff is a customer favorite
Gift Basket
A mini cheesecake, fruit & flowers
Every dessert should be as beautiful as it is delicious.
As a designer bakery, we specialize in handcrafted cakes and desserts that blend timeless artistry with exceptional flavor. Whether you're celebrating or simply treating yourself, we're here to create desserts that leave a lasting impression, one beautiful bite at a time.
Read our full storyLet's design your dream cake together.
Share your vision, event date, and flavor preferences — we'll follow up to bring it to life. A 50% deposit confirms every custom order.
Start a Custom Cake RequestFollow our journey
@buttermeupbakery.oh